Bird Quiz #1: Answer

quiz-1c1To refresh your memory, here again is the photo for Bird Quiz #1. Read no further if you still want to have a shot at identifying these birds.

I had been actively birding only a week or two when I took a trip to Yellowstone National Park. There I saw and photographed a bird just like the bottom bird in the photo. I thumbed through all the pictures of sparrows in my brand new field guide, but couldn’t ID the bird. I filed the photo under “to be identified” and forgot about it.

Several years later, I was cleaning out my files and came across the photo. Noting the wedge-shaped beak, gray-brown coloring and streaked breast and sides, I instantly recognized my mystery bird as a female House Finch. What a difference a couple of years can make!

Now, how about the top bird? Is that also a female House Finch? It has the same wedge-shaped beak (although it seems a bit slimmer), the same gray-brown coloring, and the same streaks. Some might argue that the streaks are more “crisp” rather than blurred, but I can’t really see that in this photo. The give-away, however is the gray-brown “crest” on the head. This is a female Cassin’s Finch.

The photo was taken in La Veta, a small town in southern Colorado, where both finches are abundant. Here are the males of each species. Can you tell them apart now?

cassins-finch_laveta-co_lah_5230 house-finch_carsonnaturecenter-littletonco_20100406_lah_1977r3


Yup, the one on the left is a Cassin’s Finch, as is the one below. The one on the right is a House Finch.

The red coloring on the males provides another clue. The Cassin’s Finches are more pinkish-red, while the House Finch is more orangey-red. In fact, a few individuals are orange, or even yellow!

However, we need to be careful when using color to ID a species. The position of the sun in the sky can have a profound effect on color, with the golden light of early morning or late afternoon rendering even Cassin’s Finches orangey.

I wanted to include a third finch—a Purple Finch—to make this more interesting. Sadly, in spite of trips to California and a variety of eastern states, I have yet to see a Purple Finch. Perhaps it’s my new “nemesis bird.”

One thought on “Bird Quiz #1: Answer

  1. Do you ever see Cassin’s finches in this area? It has been ages since I have really watched my house finches, but in the past I have wondered if I was seeing a Cassin’s. They sort of looked like they’ moussed their head feathers. Carey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s